Account takeover — customer auth
ABOVE APPETITEBad actor · owner K. Osei · treatment: MitigateCredential-based takeover of customer accounts (stuffing, AitM session theft). Churn lens dominates: incident actuals show two in three ATO'd accounts leave.
Scoring
Combined control effectiveness 38% · likelihood 4/5 · impact 5/5
Annualized exposure
How the churn lens is priced
2,500 exposed customers × 59% churn × $4,600 LTV = $6.78M
Assumed 40%, worth 50 customers of belief. Incidents since then: 79 of 118 affected customers left (67%), which moves the estimate to 59%.
Key risk indicators
ATO attempts / 10k logins
auth_events (warehouse) · stale
Successful ATO rate
auth_events (warehouse) · stale
MFA adoption
auth_events (warehouse) · stale
90-day churn of ATO'd accounts
Fraud ops board (Looker) · stale
Mean time to lockout
Fraud ops board (Looker) · stale
Controls
CTL-031Adaptive MFA
preventive · effectiveness 60% · tested 2026-10-03
CTL-007Session anomaly detection
detective · effectiveness 40% · tested 2026-10-24
CTL-112Credential-stuffing WAF rules
preventive · effectiveness 15% (decayed — untested since 2026-04-06)
Requirements satisfied via controls
Runs through (vendors & assets)
Assessment history
2026-10-16 · K. Osei likelihood 4/5 · impact 5/5
Likelihood up: ATO attempts trending above amber for six weeks.
2026-04-14 · Risk committee likelihood 3/5 · impact 5/5
Raised impact after peer-company ATO disclosures.
Incidents (realized risk)
INC-2026-041ATO cluster via legacy login closed
2026-07-18 · loss $412k · churn actuals: 79/118 (67%) — feeds the churn coefficient
Root cause: Credential stuffing through legacy login endpoint lacking MFA enforcement
Treatment actions